While "Rocky Handsome" was a box office hit, critics noted its reliance on clichéd tropes of mistaken identity and redemption. Some panned the over-the-top humor and predictable plot, while others praised its entertainment value and Singh’s dedication to the role. The film’s success led to informal availability on platforms like 9xMovies.in, where pirated 720p HDrip versions were shared. However, audiences were advised to opt for legal streaming services to support filmmakers and uphold intellectual property rights.

Director Nishikant Kamat himself stepped in to play the primary villain, Kevin Pereira, after another actor opted out just days before filming. Critical Reception: Style Over Substance?

The movie is noted for its realistic, brutal action choreography, particularly the knife-fighting sequences and the climax fight set to the song "Teri Toh Yaad Sataye".